header banner
Default

25 Desserts That Won at the Bake Sale


1

Iced Oatmeal Cookies

VIDEO: 8 Fun and Easy Bake Sale Recipes • Tasty
Tasty

bake sale ideas iced oatmeal cookies

Caitlin Bensel

A good old-fashioned bake sale deserves a good old-fashioned cookie—like these wholesome oatmeal cookies covered in icing! They're just like the kind you might remember as a kid.

Get the Iced Oatmeal Cookies recipe.

SHOP COOKIE SHEETS

2

Peanut Butter Brownies

VIDEO: 4 Ways To Impress At A Bake Sale
Tasty

bake sale ideas peanut butter brownies

Will Dickey

Take your brownies to the next level by combining two popular flavors: chocolate and peanut butter. It's a layered treat that everyone will love!

Get the Peanut Butter Brownies recipe.

3

Chocolate Chip Muffins

VIDEO: 24 Dessert Tricks That Only Pastry Chefs Know
Scrumdiddlyumptious

bake sale ideas chocolate chip muffins

Caitlin Bensel

The buttermilk in these muffins make them moist, fluffy, and tender. Basically, the perfect base for lots of chocolate chips!

Get the Chocolate Chip Muffins recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

4

Caramel Apple Cookies

VIDEO: 12 Amazing Bake Sale Ideas
Cake Decorist

bake sale ideas caramel apple cookies

Caitlin Bensel

These cookies are loaded with fall flavor thanks to the freshly grated apple and dried apple chips, so they're perfect for back-to-school season. But if you ask us, it's the caramel icing that really takes them over the top!

Get the Caramel Apple Cookies recipe.

5

S'mores Bars

VIDEO: Successful bake sale🎉
TRIPLE J’S BAKERY

bake sale ideas smores bars

Caitlin Bensel

It'll be hard to pass up these toasted marshmallow-topped bars, especially since they have all the flavor of s'mores without the campfire!

Get the S'mores Bars recipe.

SHOP BAKEWARE

6

Cowboy Cookies

VIDEO: Tasty's Top Dessert Recipes
Tasty Recipes

cowboy cookies stacked

Caitlin Bensel

These Texas-sized cookies are loaded with tasty mix-ins, like chocolate chips, coconut flakes, chopped pecans, and rolled oats. If you like a salty-sweet treat, try topping them with flaky sea salt.

Get the Cowboy Cookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

7

Blondies

VIDEO: A new homemade dessert, the recipe of which not everyone knows! Quick to prepare and delicious!
Herzhaftes essen

blondies on blue plate

Will Dickey

These rich, nutty, caramel-y bars are a classic bake sale treat. They're easy to make ahead and they're a hit with anyone who has a sweet tooth.

Get the Blondies recipe.

8

Pumpkin Spice Muffins

VIDEO: 7 ingenious appetizer ideas that you must try today. Puff pastry is your salvation!
Appetizing.tv-Baking Recipes

pumpkin spice muffins with frosting on wire rack

Hector Sanchez

The cream cheese frosting on these fall muffins is completely optional, but it also happens to be a very good idea. Either way—they're delicious!

Get the Pumpkin Spice Muffins recipe.

9

No-Bake Peanut Butter Bars

VIDEO: Perfect treats for the holidays and all occasions🎄🎄! no baking! no flour! melts in mouth!
VARGASAVOUR RECIPES

no bake peanut butter bars on floral napkins

Danielle Daly

This recipe comes together in just 20 minutes. Then, all you have to do is pop the bars in the fridge so they're ready for your next bake sale. It couldn't be easier!

Get the No-Bake Peanut Butter Bars recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

10

Halloween Cheesecake Bars

VIDEO: Few know the trick! Puff pastry appetizer, in the egg box, ready in 10 minutes
Appetizing.tv-Baking Recipes

halloween cheesecake bars with candy eyes and candy corn

Caitlin Bensel

With an Oreo cookie crust and a pumpkin cheesecake filling, these bars are the ultimate fall treat. You can make them with or without the fun sprinkles and Halloween candy depending on the time of year.

Get the Halloween Cheesecake Bars recipe.

SHOP SPRINKLES

11

No-Bake Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies

VIDEO: This is the best thing I've ever eaten! Dessert in 5 minutes, no oven, no condensed milk!
Bestes Essen hier

no bake chocolate oatmeal cookies with coconut stacked

Caitlin Bensel

These chewy, chocolate-y oatmeal cookies are loaded with peanut butter and chocolate hazelnut spread. If you're not a fan of coconut flakes, simply swap them out for any chopped nuts.

Get the No-Bake Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies recipe.

12

Brookies

VIDEO: An Italian family taught me this quick aperitif from puff pastry, that always saves me out!
Appetizing.tv-Baking Recipes

brookies on pink board

Will Dickey

Don't make your customers decide between brownies and cookies (that's just cruel!). Instead, make this popular mash-up that combines the best of both worlds.

Get the Brookies recipe.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

13

Apple Pie Bars

VIDEO: Awesome DIY Homemade Dessert Ideas For Christmas | Easy Dessert Recipes
So Tasty

apple pie bars on wood board

Will Dickey

Serving pie at a bake sale isn't always easy (and it requires plates). But with these apple pie bars, you can grab a slice without the fuss.

Get the Apple Pie Bars recipe.

14

Pumpkin Spice Cereal Treats

VIDEO: 8 brilliant puff pastry ideas that everyone should know!
Appetizing.tv-Baking Recipes

pumpkin spice cereal treats

KEVIN J. MIYAZAKI

Crispy, chewy cereal treats are an all-time classic. This recipe will remind you of the kind you had as a kid, but with even more flavor.

Get Ree's Pumpkin Spice Cereal Treats recipe.

15

Applesauce Cake

VIDEO: Summer dessert in 5 minutes! Everyone is looking for this recipe! Delicious and juicy cake!
Herzhaftes essen

applesauce cake with walnuts and frosting

Hector Sanchez

From the tender apple-spiced cake to the maple brown butter frosting, there's so much to love about this simple snack cake. You might even want to make an extra to round out your holiday desserts.

Get the Applesauce Cake recipe.

SHOP BAKING TOOLS

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

16

Graduation Brownie Bites

VIDEO: I don't buy tartlets. I found the ideal method, with puff pastry.
Appetizing.tv-Baking Recipes

graduation brownie bites with chocolate and candy grad hats

Ryan Dausch

These chocolate-glazed brownie bites are so good, it'll be hard to eat just one. If your bake sale is happening later in the school year, turn the brownies into graduation hats using chocolate squares and sour candy belts.

Get Ree's Graduation Brownie Bites recipe.

17

Peanut Butter Blossoms

VIDEO: 15 Cake Decoration & Plating Hacks to Impress Your Dinner Guests! So Yummy
So Yummy

peanut butter blossoms on sheet pan

Will Dickey

Who can resist the classic combination of chocolate and peanut butter? Roll the dough in sanding sugar (using your school colors) for even more school spirit.

Get the Peanut Butter Blossoms recipe.

18

Mini Pumpkin Cheesecakes

VIDEO: Easy And Delicious Cupcakes To Make For A Bake Sale • Tasty
Tasty

mini pumpkin cheesecakes with whipped cream

Will Dickey

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

19

Oreo Truffles

VIDEO: Four easy desserts great for a bake sale
azcentral.com and The Arizona Republic

oreo truffles with white sprinkles

Brian Woodcock

Here's a fun bake sale idea: Top these no-bake truffles with pretty sprinkles or nonpareils, then wrap a few of them up in cellophane bags with ribbon for an impressive presentation.

Get Ree's Oreo Truffles recipe.

20

Pumpkin Snickerdoodles

VIDEO: Dessert Ideas for a Bake Sale, Fundraiser, Auction, or JUST BECAUSE
TheCallieDaeWay

pumpkin snickerdoodles

Will Dickey

Sources


Article information

Author: Frances Lawson

Last Updated: 1702389604

Views: 1063

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (94 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frances Lawson

Birthday: 1926-12-02

Address: 1434 Patel Roads, East Justin, NC 18762

Phone: +4835754928532221

Job: Virtual Reality Developer

Hobby: Stargazing, Backpacking, Hiking, Puzzle Solving, Fishing, Woodworking, Swimming

Introduction: My name is Frances Lawson, I am a intrepid, unswerving, Precious, honest, exquisite, Open, cherished person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.